Luke連養父母都冚家剷埋啊,仲要望住咁冚家剷啊。
Luke New Hope已經炸鳩咗Death Star喇
人地luke一步一步成長
第一集尾開始感受到原力,幫佢打爆死星
第二集開始識運用原力,一開始念動力,訓練用後就完全運用到
第三集真正覺醒,可以檔光槍,真係真正成熟,仲識埋自己整光劍,原力鎖,催眠人等技能
一步一步講主角好快咁逐樣逐樣識先係顯得佢勁架
Rey一開波打敗ben 連訓練都無,你唔係覺得rey強囉,係覺得ben廢
而反觀Rey 果邊連一個訓練都未做過就無程程做咗Last Jedi
所以Rey 嘅所有嘢根本就係Setting 砌出嚟,根本比唔到一個係佢自己Earn返嚟嘅感覺,而係Given by The-One-Above-All ,仲要同我講佢係Jedi 嘅模範
咁咪即係一種無付出過,總之我天生勁我大晒,仲衰過你血統
人地luke當年經過幾多挑戰訓練先得架
家人死晒,被隻怪打傷過,被Yoda 訓練救訓,被老豆斬左隻手,宜家漫畫仲係咁係4-6中間講佢依三年的經歷
打錯,仲係4同5
6之後都係有一篇漫畫講佢有幾強
無錯,就算係有The Chosen One 血統都要九九八十一難,因為唔係苦難中建立出嚟嘅主角,觀眾根本唔會覺得佢耀眼。E.g. 鋼鍊嘅愛德華兄弟係一個好例子。
同埋佢哋好鍾意有一個論調係:Skywalker 可以係The Chosen One,點解Rey 唔可以係原力之女
就好似已經證明咗佢係原力之女咁喎 有鬼講過咩
就算佢真係咩原力之女,都好似無傷登天咁,都係一張白紙,都係果句:Why Her?
Tony咁撚有米都要係被人捉左的情況下整個mark 1出黎都係打敗d二打六炸
之後要係咁實驗,失敗過無數次再加堅定決心先整d勁甲出黎做英雄
Rey經驗過d咩?咁快打敗Ben?
開咁大個頭(冇train過既rey打贏學晒light同dark side加skywalker bloodline既ben) 跟住草草了事話係nobody
會唔會又係眼高手低?
正前傳就係知二個主角第一集係未訓練
所以打戲都交俾obi
呢度
Exactly. Those collection of scenes felt almost cartoon / episodic in a way. Once again, everything was made very easy for Rey.
There was no true struggle or conflicts in this movie. I felt the greatest weakness of TFA was Rey's Mary-Sue experiences (everything works out in her favor), she has no flaws.
TLJ made this even worse. Her connection with Kylo should have had a meaningful impact on her character, but it ultimately lead to nowhere for the sake of "subverted expectations."
Her time as a brief prisoner was pointless as well. She got into a difficult situation, Kylo helped her out, but since he's too weak to ever defeat her, she escapes easily, no biggie. A dumb decision was rewarded with the most powerful Sith's unlucky death. But don't worry, Kylo Ren is still bad, so it wasn't predictable after all. All for the sake of "subverted expectations."
The "big reveal" that her parents "were nobodies" served absolutely no purpose. What exactly was it supposed to accomplish? How did that change her in any way at all? I felt the purpose of that reveal was once again to "subvert expectations."
There comes a point when "Subverting expectations" can absolutely destroy the intended message / narrative / and characters. TLJ took this to the extreme (I can go on and on with examples). Trying way too hard to be unpredictable was my biggest caveat with the movie, but certainly not the only one.
所以啲人成日話得連登仔咁諗喎,Reddit 大把人講緊呢樣嘢啦