[借ac] 係美國新聞學院寫咗篇自己唔係中國人嘅文

係呀，根本成個中國人既concept都係吹出黎呃人。

Ethnically Chinese 係吹出黎，冇依樣野

如果要分，應該係叫漢人北佬個d明顯係第種人啦

用基因去分最中性

清末班人想繼承個帝國而老作出嚟
混合帝國主義同民族主義嘅畸形產品

民族係個social construct, 大多數人認為有就會有. 而且ethnically chinese好多時係講文化上嘅嘢(講中文寫中文, 揸筷子之類)多過真係驗dna. 正如普遍都會認為台灣人係華人, 但原住民好明顯唔係華人啦.

我響Reddit寫過N篇呢類文章, 又長又多, 不過冇用的, 永遠都有五毛跟住你黎屌跟住downvote到你篇文失蹤

想問樓主，學校有咩反應？ 有冇話怕麻煩叫你收皮咁？
見班中國學生篇文都幾 aggressive 下，其實可以開佢波

The identity issue is way more complicated than what ethnic group a person belongs to, which country's passport a person has or what language a person speaks.
In my trip in Europe, someone from the States argued that HongKongers are Chinese as we speak Chinese.
If that's true then majority of the States' population would be British because they speak English.
Maybe you live in a place where identity crisis is not an issue so you don't understand.
Is Obama a American or African? You can't identify him as an African simply because his skin is black. Many people in the world don't possess a passport. So where do they belong? You can see that identity, for some people, is not as straight forward as you might think.

The government of a country can change, boundary certainly always changes over time.
Australia was once owned by the indigenous Australian. The Roman Empire and Mongol Empire no longer exist. And imagine that you are living in a land occupied by the Nazis in WW2, are you automatically an Nazi once they have marched into your city?

幫你執咗執 但其實你用nazi做例子好容易俾人執住嚟講 但obama個例子ok 鬼佬可能會覺得relatable

hi 非洲同胞

大多數人認爲啱既野就啱，咁難怪香港人比人當係支那人

支持

大家都係非洲人

支持

所以要係正式媒體度出啦

美國

都唔係淨係美國 根本全世界邊度都多 我屌

原來真係好多00後得支那籍

無問題 但唔會係香港 想大家認清事實唔洗打飛機
認清爭取緊啲咩

有時有啲嘢唔係用啱同錯嚟去分嘅. 一個大部份人都認同嘅社會概念, 我地好難否定佢嘅存在.

而我自己就不嬲都認為, 香港要爭取更多嘅政治權利, 同我地係唔係華人, 中國人係咪華人, 根本係冇關係. 所以對我嚟講, 我冇誘因去唔承認ethnically Chinese依個概念.

支持

可惜我英文差

上次睇到都O左，有個係問點解大陸咁aggressive 想接管香港，有個係香港大陸學生話係商家管治下香港越黎越差，科技又無，所以中共先出手救香港

個reply 係勁多like ，同玩得quora既五毛真係全部都名校出身，講既垃圾又好似呃到下人咁

其實係連登打曬飛機咁係無意思出面世界既人根本就唔會聽到所謂既本土聲音