點解覺得數學公式難背?

220 回覆
5 Like 18 Dislike
2017-09-27 13:28:54
仲有一個
Why radius is perpendicular to tangent at the point of contact


Just a result from vector calculus that, using dot product in circular motion:
r‧r' = 0

Where r' is the first derivative of r

如果係中學生問你呢個問題呢
一樣用vector cal拋鳩佢

所以數理化卷必須要設立 bonus 常識題去西走考試機器

岩呀龜sir最鐘意咁樣拋9啲中學生
2017-09-27 13:55:49
太抽象
對我實際生活生存無直接關係

抽象嗰度,係咪例如一句描述一個圖形嘅句子,你想像唔到個圖形?
無直接關係……等同無興趣喔?

三角嗰D sin 2a = 一抽乜鬼 之類咪死記硬背囉, 老實講prove 左點黎都唔會記得住

compound angle formulae 好似係由 cos(x+y) 開始用 polar coordinate prove

一切trigo由 unit circle 開始
2017-09-27 14:28:27
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野
2017-09-27 14:57:44
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係
2017-09-27 14:59:01
中學嘅數好多都可以自己推出嚟
好多學生掛住盲目操數唔溫書
無理過嗰課本身講啲乜
自然覺得難記

呢啲人一上到中四即刻出事

Just call an arts stream student to explain:

For an equation x^2 + ax + b=0 where a and b are integers.
Explain why when the roots are all complex, b>0.

死撚開啦烏大龜
2017-09-27 15:17:53
其實點解sum of root係a+b , product of root係ab , 教科書似乎一直以嚟都冇解釋過

呢個有咩好解釋
要解嘅係Sum of roots = -b/a

仲有product of roots係c/a,點解?

vieta theorem
2017-09-27 15:25:00
其實dse數學教育根本有問題,好似故意要做低數學好嘅學生咁
剩係m要另外揾時間上堂已經夠癡線
仲要cut走晒啲proof,冇proof仲叫數學?
2017-09-27 15:27:47
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof
2017-09-27 15:35:44
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof

無讀過proof就唔好話自己讀數學
2017-09-27 15:38:08
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof

無讀過proof就唔好話自己讀數學

無話自己讀過calculus
如果唔係maths compu應該好多人揀唔讀
2017-09-27 16:45:51
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof

無讀過proof就唔好話自己讀數學

無話自己讀過calculus
如果唔係maths compu應該好多人揀唔讀


dse core 要玩proof唔會好難,不過耐冇用就會唔記得點prove。我中學連proof都明埋。

Calculus 我都無視哂d proof, 知咩情況做咩但再深入就唔知。坦白講,yr1 d in 你識做真係夠做,佢又唔會問到好深入。讀緊surface integral, multiple integral , div thm etc, d proof 煩左睇都唔想睇,知點用同點做就算。
2017-09-27 17:44:00
仲有一個
Why radius is perpendicular to tangent at the point of contact


Just a result from vector calculus that, using dot product in circular motion:
r‧r' = 0

Where r' is the first derivative of r

如果係中學生問你呢個問題呢
一樣用vector cal拋鳩佢

我覺得呢個無問題
同埋淨係differentiate w.r.t. t唔算咩vector cal啦
2017-09-27 18:00:37
太抽象
對我實際生活生存無直接關係
2017-09-27 18:01:06
太抽象
對我實際生活生存無直接關係

屌覆錯
2017-09-27 18:18:16
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof

無讀過proof就唔好話自己讀數學

無話自己讀過calculus
如果唔係maths compu應該好多人揀唔讀


dse core 要玩proof唔會好難,不過耐冇用就會唔記得點prove。我中學連proof都明埋。

Calculus 我都無視哂d proof, 知咩情況做咩但再深入就唔知。坦白講,yr1 d in 你識做真係夠做,佢又唔會問到好深入。讀緊surface integral, multiple integral , div thm etc, d proof 煩左睇都唔想睇,知點用同點做就算。

non math major既話根本冇所謂

一知半解就得

講多句

dse core以至小學數學既proof根本一d都唔容易
2017-09-27 18:34:27
其實冇乜點解,有d野你同我可能覺得好易,但係一定有人覺得難ga,或者掉番轉
2017-09-27 18:35:33

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof

無讀過proof就唔好話自己讀數學

無話自己讀過calculus
如果唔係maths compu應該好多人揀唔讀


dse core 要玩proof唔會好難,不過耐冇用就會唔記得點prove。我中學連proof都明埋。

Calculus 我都無視哂d proof, 知咩情況做咩但再深入就唔知。坦白講,yr1 d in 你識做真係夠做,佢又唔會問到好深入。讀緊surface integral, multiple integral , div thm etc, d proof 煩左睇都唔想睇,知點用同點做就算。

non math major既話根本冇所謂

一知半解就得

講多句

dse core以至小學數學既proof根本一d都唔容易

小學嘅proof係最難
2017-09-27 19:15:40
Funny questons:
Why volume of sphere (4/3)pie r^3?
Why surface area of sphere is 4pie r^2?
Is it a coincidence that surface area of sphere is the derivative of its volume?

Volume: Use polar coordinate to do double integration.
Surface area: Out of post-2005 HKAL Pure Math Syllabus

就好似咁 唔係話要你背唔理解
但係唔通你叫個中二學生理解咩係d in?
背式快好多囉 下下都講理解要記多幾多野

責任上係要同佢講呢舊嘢有得解
但唔係中二程度做到嘅事
總之唔可以俾學生覺得呢啲嘢係好似science咁用實驗verify到就當係

咁咪直情玩死埋啲science仔
下下都要mathematical proof 淨係俾你地Phys maths佬讀得啦
利申:由calculus開始無視哂啲proof

無讀過proof就唔好話自己讀數學

無話自己讀過calculus
如果唔係maths compu應該好多人揀唔讀


dse core 要玩proof唔會好難,不過耐冇用就會唔記得點prove。我中學連proof都明埋。

Calculus 我都無視哂d proof, 知咩情況做咩但再深入就唔知。坦白講,yr1 d in 你識做真係夠做,佢又唔會問到好深入。讀緊surface integral, multiple integral , div thm etc, d proof 煩到睇都唔想睇,知點用同點做就算。

non math major既話根本冇所謂

一知半解就得

講多句

dse core以至小學數學既proof根本一d都唔容易


都係
如果由數學最底層明上去,係好難。
但如果由中學教科書比你嘅proof, 要明到就唔難。始終人地出得書係中學生能力handle到。

至於大學,好多都係考到試就算,唔會深究。因為要明哂幾花腦汁
2017-09-28 01:50:12
如果有個網 集齊晒由古至今
數學家嘅論文就好 好想狂煲晒佢

Google scholar..
有啲太舊只有paper work
或者無英文版。。。
2017-09-28 01:58:13
如果有個網 集齊晒由古至今
數學家嘅論文就好 好想狂煲晒佢

Google scholar..
有啲太舊只有paper work
或者無英文版。。。


講真你就咁睇abstract都唔知要睇幾耐
我諗就算攞fields medal都唔會睇晒所有論文
有啲proof 70幾80頁
最多睇晒自己area嗰啲
數學發展愈黎愈專
如果你搵到兩個area之間有咩新嘅common point都係神級人物
吹水台自選台熱 門最 新手機台時事台政事台World體育台娛樂台動漫台Apps台遊戲台影視台講故台健康台感情台家庭台潮流台美容台上班台財經台房屋台飲食台旅遊台學術台校園台汽車台音樂台創意台硬件台電器台攝影台玩具台寵物台軟件台活動台電訊台直播台站務台黑 洞