發現 唔少人對於係澳洲讀完大學番黎既同學有誤解 我盡量解答

UNSW finance faculty staff : https://www.business.unsw.edu.au/about/schools/banking-finance/faculty-people#1531307271318

Rik Sen - PhD, New York University | MBA, Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta

Jianfeng Shen - PhD, National University of Singapore

Kyung Hwan Shim - PhD, University of British Columbia | MSc, University of British Columbia | BCom, University of British Columbia

Jared Stanfield - PhD, University of Washington | MS, University of Washington

Jo-Ann Suchard - PhD, University of New South Wales | MCom (Hons), University of New South Wales

Peter Swan AO FRSN FASSA - PhD, Monash University | BEc (Hons), Australian National University

Wing Wah Tham - PhD, University of Warwick | MSc, Imperial College, UK | BEng, Nanyang Technological University of Singapore

Elvira Sojli - School of Banking & Finance - PhD, University of Warwick, UK | MSc, University of Warwick, UK | BSc, London School of Economics, UK

Carole Comerton-Forde - PhD, University of Sydney | BCom(Hons), University of Sydney

Kingsley Fong - PhD, University of Sydney | BCom (Hons), University of New South Wales

Chris adam - PhD, Harvard university

Konark Saxena - PhD, University of California at Los Angeles

Renee Adams - PhD, University of Chicago | MS, Stanford University

Pedro Barroso - PhD, NOVA School of Business and Economics

Thomas Ruf - PhD, University of British Columbia | MSc, UCLA

Zhian Chen - PhD, University of New South Wales | MCom, University of Sydney | BE, Shanghai Merc Marine

Oleg Chuprinin - PhD Finance (INSEAD Business School)

David Feldman - PhD, Northwestern University | MS, Northwestern University

Mark Humphery-Jenner - PhD, UNSW

Chang Mo Kang - PhD, The University of Texas at Austin | MS, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology | BA, Seoul National University

Robert Tumarkin - PhD, New York University | MPhil, New York University | MBA (Honors), New York University | ScB (Honors), Brown University

Zhaoxia Xu - PhD, University of Toronto

Jaehoon Lee - PhD, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign | MS, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology | BS, Computer Science (major), Applied Mathematics (minor), Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology

Ron Masulis - PhD, University of Chicago | MBA, University of Chicago | BA (High Hons), Northeastern University

Fariborz Moshirian - PhD, Monash University | MEc, Monash University

Natalie Oh - PhD, University of New South Wales | MCom, University of Sydney | BEng (Hons), BCom, University of Sydney

Peter Kien Pham - PhD, Monash University

Li Yang - PhD, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign | MS, Tsinghua University | BS, Tsinghua University

Kristle Romero Cortés - PhD Finance, Boston College | BA (Honours), Northwestern University

Jason Zein - PhD, University of New South Wales | BCom (First Class Hons.), University of New South Wales

Henry Yip - PhD, University of New South Wales | BEc (Hons), Macquarie University

UNSW econ faculty staff : https://www.business.unsw.edu.au/about/schools/economics/faculty-people#1531308647947

Mike Keane - PhD Economics, Brown University | MA Economics, Brown University | BS Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T)

Peter Kriesler - PhD, University of Cambridge | M.Ec. (Hons) B. Ec. (Hons), University of Sydney

SeoJeong (Jay) Lee - PhD Economics, University of Wisconsin-Madison

Hongyi Li - PhD Economics, Harvard University

Jiangtao Li - PhD in Economics, National University of Singapore

Hodaka Morita - PhD Economics and MBA, Cornell University | BEc University of Tokyo

Tess Stafford - PhD Economics, University of Texas, Austin

Arghya Ghosh - PhD, University of Minnesota, USA

Gautam Bose - PhD, University of California, Los Angeles

Steven Callander - PhD, Stanford University

Robert Kohn - PhD, Econometrics, ANU

Chris Carter - BSc (Hons), Sydney | PhD, UNSW

Keiichi Kawai - PhD, Northwestern University | MA, BA in Economics, Kyoto University

Richard Holden - Ph.D, A.M. Harvard | BEc (Hons) Sydney

Anton Kolotilin - PhD Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)

Valentyn Panchenko - PhD, University of Amsterdam, Netherlands

Arpita Chatterjee - PhD and MA, Princeton University

Sang-Wook (Stanley) Cho -

Erwin Diewert - PhD, University of California at Berkeley | MA, University of British Columbia | BA, University of British Columbia

Denise Doiron - PhD and MA, University of British Columbia

Denzil Fiebig - University of California, Los Angeles

Gigi Foster - PhD in economics, University of Maryland, College Park | BA, magna cum laude in Ethics, Politics, and Economics, Yale University

Gabriele Gratton - PhD, Boston University | MSc, London School of Economics and Political Sciences

UNSW DEAN, FAC HEAD, DIRECTOR PROGRAM HEADLIST : https://www.business.unsw.edu.au/about/business-school/staff

Chris Styles (Dean) - BCom (Hons), University of Western Australia | PhD, London Business School

Leisa Sargent (Senior Deputy Dean, AGSM Scholar) - School of Management - BA M Org Psych, University of Queensland| Ph.D. Rotman School of Management University of Toronto

Mark Uncles (Deputy Dean (Education) and Professor of Marketing) - School of Marketing - PhD, University of Bristol | UK BSc (Hons)

Clinton Free (Professor, AGSM Fellow, Academic Director, AGSM) - School of Accounting - DPhil, Oxford | LLB, UNSW | BCom, (First-Class Honours, University Medal), UNSW | CPA

Richard Dunford (Associate Dean, International & External Relations) - BCA, BA (Hons), (Wellington) | PhD (ANU)

Elizabeth Carson ( Professor, Associate Dean (Research) ) - School of Accounting - BCom (Hons), UNSW | MCom, UNSW | PhD, UNSW | Chartered Accountant (CA)

Nick Wailes (Director, AGSM and Deputy Dean at UNSW Business School) - PhD, university of sydney

Chris Adam (Associate Dean, program professor) - PhD, Harvard university | MA, UWA

Mandy Cheng (AGSM Scholar, Professor, Head of School) - School of Accounting - PhD Accounting, UNSW | MCom (Hons), UNSW | BCom (Hons), UNSW | FCPA (Aust)

Carole Comerton-Forde (Head of the School of Banking and Finance, Professor of Finance) - School of Banking ＆ Finance - PhD, University of Sydney | BCom(Hons), University of Sydney | GAICD, Australian Institute of Company Directors

Arghya Ghosh (Head of School, Professor) - School of Economics - PhD, University of Minnesota, USA | MA, Delhi School of Economics, India | BSc, Presidency College, India

Patrick Finnegan (Head of information system) - School of Information Systems - PhD Information Systems, University of Warwick, England | MA Higher Education, University College Cork, Ireland

Jack Cadeaux (Head of marketing) - School of Marketing - PhD, University of California, Berkeley | MA, Stanford University

Karin Sanders (Head of School of Management, AGSM Scholar, OB and HRM and Director, Centre for Innovation and Entrepreneurship) - School of Management - PhD, University of Groningen, the Netherlands | BA, MA, Psychology and Research Methods, University of Groningen, the Netherlands

Bill Schworm (President member) - PhD, University of Washington | MA, University of Virginia |

已經po晒每個fac最勁嗰啲phd grad 嘅教授出嚟
牛津mit哈佛等等各大學畢業求其數都有幾個
我睇吓你今次又點兜

唔好又側側膊搵其他嘢去轉移話題呀

所以話你廢真係無話錯，比較都唔識好心就咪出嚟獻醜，比較平台都無，重自我感覺良好咁。

Elaborate又唔識，po咁多嘢出嚟有乜柒用？表達到啲乜？

其實你係咪唔夠膽做比較所以淨係單方面po UNSW啲staff。同埋揀啲勁嘅出嚟有乜用？而家UST又唔係無。

我就會咁揀個比較平台，Assume Department Head係最猛料嗰個，再比較每個兩間U都有嘅Department，佢哋嘅Head拎PhD間U喺THE World Universities 2018嘅排名，綜合較低者勝。

（如果無Head則以現時最高級別頂上，即Acting Head，Department個名亦未必完全一樣，但一定係同一方向）

Accounting：
HKUST: Prof. Kevin C. W. CHEN, Head, Chair Professor
PhD 1985 University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Accounting

UNSW: Mandy Cheng AGSM Scholar, Professor, Head of School School of Accounting
PhD Accounting, UNSW

Rank: 37 vs 85

Economics:
HKUST: Prof. Siu Fai LEUNG Head and Professor
Ph.D. 1987 University of Chicago, Economics

UNSW: Arghya Ghosh Head of School, Professor
School of Economics - PhD, University of Minnesota, USA

Rank: 9 vs 56

Finance（HKUST）Finance & Banking（UNSW）
HKUST: Prof. Chu ZHANG Acting Head/ Professor
PhD, University of Chicago, Finance,1992

UNSW: Carole Comerton-Forde Head of the School of Banking and Finance, Professor of Finance
PhD, University of Sydney

Rank: 9 vs 61

Information Systems & Operations Management（HKUST）Information Systems & Technology Management（UNSW）
HKUST: Prof. Shaohui ZHENG Head, Chair Professor, Operations Management
PhD 1994 Columbia University, Operations Research

UNSW: Patrick Finnegan Professor
School of Information Systems - PhD Information Systems, University of Warwick, England

Rank: 14 vs 91

Management
HKUST: Prof. Yaping GONG
Ph.D. The Ohio State University, Human Resources Management and Organizational Behavior

UNSW: Karin Sanders Head of School of Management
School of Management - PhD, University of Groningen, the Netherlands

Rank: 70 vs 83

Marketing:
HKUST: Prof. A V MUTHUKRISHNAN Head , Professor
PhD University of Florida, Marketing

UNSW: Jack Cadeaux Professor, Head of School School of Marketing
PhD, University of California, Berkeley

Rank: 143 vs 18

Total: 282 vs 394 有錯或者你覺得哩個討論平台唔好嘅歡迎自己再作比較，都係嗰句，一件事有咁多觀點角度，總有方法嘅。

本身係想搵By Subject嘅Ranking嚟比較，但THE同QS都無咁細分嘅Ranking，都係去到Business & Economics之類再無再細分，但又無理由某啲Department拎By Subject Ranking去計某啲又唔拎，所以劃一拎World Ranking去排。

大佬呀，起碼咁先叫比較啦吓話，連比較平台都唔識搵。認真你中學生都不如，但我諗你連認識到自己有幾廢嘅認知能力都缺乏

以下嘅嘢一半想潤鳩你一半係真心講嘅，其實你會唔會係有啲咩認知障礙或者讀寫果難之類？因為廿幾歲人連Present一個正常少少嘅比較都做唔到真係比較少見。

或者我哋簡化少少，喺學術界一個Professor猛料與否都係睇喺Top嘅Journal出到幾多文；同一時間，坊間啲大學評級好大程度都係睇一個Faculty嘅Research Output嚟排名。

簡而言之，越多猛人自然越多Output、排名自然高，師資高低與排名始終密不可分。

要比較商學院師資嘅話睇吓排名或者都知道多少。

THE World University Rankings by subject： Business & Economics
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/world-university-rankings/by-subject
HKUST 14
HKU 31
PolyU 39
CU 52
UNSW 55

你間U同你一樣唔爭氣喎

1. 比較嘅話梗係成個fac 比較啦 淨係攞個head 比
Po 晒啲老師出嚟代表緊/表達出我哋學校啲私資有幾勁（之前你響度話我哋學校啲老師係野雞呀嘛咁我咪po晒成個fac啲pro俾你睇吓我哋學校D pro 有幾勁而唔係你所講乜嘢野雞大學畢業 ）

2. Unsw 嗰啲響勁嘅大學攞到phd 嘅數量仲多過Ust 例如好似Unsw Econ fin fac 咁！我咁講我諗你應該冇異議啦掛 btw Unsw Econ fin fac 有好幾個MIT 同Harvard phd grad 而Ust 冇 你自己睇下 何來Unsw 有個啲Ust 冇

3.Assume department head 係最勁嗰個？如果department head 響啲唔係最頂尖嘅大學PhD 畢業就等於佢個fac其他Professor lecturer 係廢或者唔可以響啲最頂尖嘅大學例如mit Harvard 畢業？
係比較嘅話都係比較整體成個fac啲Professor 有冇料啦！你話咁樣比較嘅話係咪在公平啲？

4. 點解你無啦啦攞THE 個大學排名去比較嘅
你之前唔係用qs 個排名以圖去證明university of Chicago 個Econ ranking 世界第一（雖然你最後係證明錯咗 qs ranking 裏面世界第一係mit or Harvard )？
點解你今次唔用qs 又或者用晒呢兩個大學排名指標去比較？

5. Qs ranking 冇細分 by subject ranking ?

6. 本身比較平台梗係攞各間大學嘅fac去比較 我有po到每間大學fac staff 嘅link

QS ranking by subject :

accounting & finance

unsw 10 > ust 16 > hku 28


Econ

ust 28 > unsw 30 > hku 35


business & management

ust 16 > unsw 22 > hku 26

大家料子差不多

好呀你話點比較好？成個Faculty比姐係所有Teaching Staff都要包含晒，咁又用咩指標去比較？唔做sampling，成個Faculty啲Professor嚟比較，你要表演我實睇埋佢呀。

QS入面吾城試過爬CU頭添，你而家咪似足城大仔。對啲肯比錢刷Ranking嘅U嚟講根本無公信力，咪拎少啲人詬病嘅THE嚟比

完全封鎖「Hi你個west」後將隱藏所有該會員的主題、回覆及被引用回覆。如日後需解除封鎖，請於「帳號」內的「封鎖會員」中設定。

唔阻你打J，不過你真係搵到方法唔做sampling、成個Faculty所有Professor一齊比較畀我學吓嘢又唔拘，搵你個分身Account定friend Po或者Quote嚟睇啦。

不過以你咁嘅智商唔抱期望就係啦

DSE都有十幾分

又黎引戰 撚狗

澳洲嘅大學(G8)其實一啲都唔垃圾, 教學質素, 研究質素都係好好
只不過收好多差嘅國際學生就係真嘅
大學個營運模式實在太重學店feel


利申: 垃圾學生之一(已grad)

poly 52 > CU 52

poly 39 > CU 52

用 department head 比去真心 on9
department head好多時候教少書 教一科
行政工作邊個做?

我覺得收國際學生的標準調低無咩問題 只要考試難道不往下調就 ok 保證畢業生的質素
差學生會自然淘汰 大學同時又可以多賺學費 一舉多得

咁你又唔諗吓點解大家都係department head都係你講嘅少教書做行政，咁又會有一邊特別廢。其實UST marketing department head間U ranking夠低啦，淨係哩一個department都輸成百排名，我又有冇搵借口？

個faculty真係勁嘅話就算一個department輸，其他都贏得返，而家UNSW咁多department都輸又點計？

係，成個department入面可以有人學歷勁過個head，咁哩點同樣適用於UST，UST Marketing第二高職位個chair已經係UCLA，我比較嗰陣點解唔提？因為唔會咁樣輸打贏要囉

淨係識針住UNSW輸啲位嚟挑骨頭，又唔見你諗吓吓我個準則對所有department都劃一，唔似你班友某啲department輸就嗌不公，Marketing Dept贏就唔出聲。一個department輸你可以話無代表性，到兩個、三個、四個、五個都輸，贏就贏一個，都證明唔到啲乜？

而且我唔係直接5:1判UST勝，係加晒咁多個ranking再比較，UNSW marketing dept都贏返過百排名啦，我係做馬嘅直接宣佈5:1唔好？

都係嗰句，觀點角度個個不同，你有自己比較方法大可以po出嚟，破論又唔立論，畀你拗到下世都develop唔到自己一套論點。

講到最尾，畀你拗贏澳洲U勁又點，都與你班本身廢到無輪嘅國際生無關啦，由其上面位會員，由始至終識嘅嘢只有copy n paste，有校友搵到好工又如何？喺你班友口中最多咪我師兄乜乜乜嚟打飛機，因為你班友網上泥漿摔角都打成咁，難以想像真人一開口可以吐到啲咩象牙出嚟。

廢人始終係廢人，無料扮大袋有乜謂？

用錯咗同住嘅人嘅device覆

去澳洲讀既大部分係香港入唔到u先去
台就擺明窮撚啦
英美多d top既人去讀名校（澳洲邊有名校 全撚部係教育商業化既產品）當然都仲有一堆係香港入唔到u先去d英美二三線大學
加唔知
總括而言 最後都係睇你讀咩大學

澳洲=垃圾

我覺得讀書曬咗你