Dunning-Kruger effect條curve

34 回覆
11 Like 4 Dislike
2023-09-28 13:33:57
成日見啲人攞下面呢條curve嚟代表DK effect


但實際上嘅份paper所形容嘅DK effect同條curve係兩回事

Perceived logical reasoning ability and test performance as a function of actual test performance, taken from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/12688660_Unskilled_and_Unaware_of_It_How_Difficulties_in_Recognizing_One%27s_Own_Incompetence_Lead_to_Inflated_Self-Assessments

其實條curve係喺邊度嚟,又點解會傳得咁廣?
2023-10-23 14:15:47
呢個都係一個問題,psychology嘅實驗成日都被質疑好難replicate
不過我冇咩詳細睇過有關呢方面嘅嘢



我個主要疑問係,成日喺連登同埋外國forums上面見到第一幅圖條curve,suggest冇能力者嘅自信 > 有能力者
但睇返篇文(唔理篇文嘅conclusion係咪solid先),會發現其實有能力者嘅「自信」其實 > 冇能力者
只不過佢哋會underestimate自己,而冇能力者會overestimate自己

所以好奇條curve喺邊度彈出嚟
2023-10-23 14:17:51
至於replicability問題,今日晏啲可以搵搵有冇人試過重做呢個實驗
不過我psychology嘅知識貧瘠,可能需要連登巴打絲打提點一下
2023-10-23 15:21:03
true
我之前睇咗下個Many Labs Replication Project,發現psy嘅replication crisis真係好嚴重
不過dk effect好似都冇咩特別嘅real world application,啲人都係當meme噉spread,又少咗incentive去replicate


btw
真係見有人re-evaluate過DK effect,話係artefact
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289620300271

又有人再evaluate個re-evulation,話有effect,但個effect好細
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289622000988?via%3Dihub
唔想用手機睇文,遲啲先睇
2023-10-23 15:24:34
re-evaluation 今日不停打錯字
2023-10-23 15:31:23
係,初學者overestimate自己呢個現象喺網上成日見,可能啲人多機會用,好易廣傳
有個effect攞出嚟講又好似頭頭是道噉

但最好奇係幅graph係邊條友整出嚟,重上埋wiki
2023-10-23 22:18:46
confidence= perceived score - actual score?
會得到mt. stupid 到 plateau
0 knowledge 到 mt. stupid 就求奇拉直線上

幅圖出現係因為一幅圖一條線易解釋啲掛
2023-10-23 22:22:32
去唔到plateau
top嗰班人係underestimate自己,perceived score - actual score係negative
2023-10-23 22:31:07
咁就應該係 y(confidence) = x + (perceived score - actual score)
2023-10-23 22:34:12
唔係好明
confidence = competence + perceived ability - actual ability?
2023-10-23 22:35:34
定你意思x係個constant term,逼佢上positive
2023-10-23 22:51:34
x = y
confidence (y, 0-100) = competence (x, 0-100) + (perceived score - actual score)

佢應該撈埋咗好幾樣想講嘅野
2023-10-23 22:57:51
competence唔係practically equivalent to actual score咩
唔係要點理解
2023-10-23 23:14:02
咁幅圖就係plot perceived score against actual score

我個諗法係
幅圖base on confidence = competence
with an arbitrary value 0-100/1000 etc.

然後用(perceived score - actual score)表達overconfident/underconfident

sorry for the poor presentation
2023-10-23 23:33:13

睇下我有冇理解錯你講咩

如果真係,個plot都幾複雜
正常人會諗到用x = y做base咩

另外如果係噉,個slope of enlightenment應該要打橫 / less steep than plateau of sustainability
plateau of sustainability應該要follow x=y,變slope先make sense
2023-10-23 23:45:26
大概係咁
呢啲圖唔洗太講究啦我諗
表達到
1. overconfident
2. back to normal (despair)
3. correctly know yourself (slope of enlighten)
4. underconfident (plateau)
用返D-K 原本幅圖難睇啲

再者咁樣plot 個arbitrary value 細啲幅圖出嚟會juicy 啲
mt. stupid 可以變 mt. stupid Everest
2023-10-23 23:49:05
講得通
thx ching
2023-10-23 23:51:47
睇過啲質疑嘅文,好多都focus on statistical analyses嘅artefacts
咩regression toward the mean我真心識條撚

冇能力,睇下有冇其他人望下講下
2023-10-24 22:23:00
當然條curve本身唔係statistically derived
但有人質疑個effect本身(which the curve attempts to describe)係statistical artefact

btw here's a stackexchange page discussing the same topic
https://psychology.stackexchange.com/questions/17825/what-is-the-primary-source-of-the-mount-stupid-graphic
吹水台自選台熱 門最 新手機台時事台政事台World體育台娛樂台動漫台Apps台遊戲台影視台講故台健康台感情台家庭台潮流台美容台上班台財經台房屋台飲食台旅遊台學術台校園台汽車台音樂台創意台硬件台電器台攝影台玩具台寵物台軟件台活動台電訊台直播台站務台黑 洞